Relatively little is known about Fineshade Abbey - another of the ranks of excellent country houses which led quiet existences. Fineshade occupied a beautiful position in a heavily wooded area of Northamptonshire which probably gave it it's name.
Originally this position was the site of Castle Hymel which was demolished at the beginning of King John's reign around 1200 by Richard Engayne the elder, Lord of Blatherwycke. Engayne built a Augustinian priory slightly to the north-west of the castle, called the church of St. Mary of Castle-Hymel though it soon afterwards became known as Fineshade. The Engayne family endowed various land to the priory until they owned a significant estate stretching as far as Blatherwycke nearly four miles away. For over 300 years the priory continued it's work - bar some allegations of excess in the mid-14th century and a fire in around 1420 - until the Dissolution of the Monasteries. Richard Harrington, who became prior in 1526, was one of the few to accede to the demands of the king and he, along with six fellow canons, acknowledged the supremacy of the king on 26 August 1534. This did not save the house as on Palm Sunday 1536 Humphrey Stafford wrote to Cromwell from Blatherwycke to ask that he be gifted the priory (and the lands, no doubt). Not that Stafford was a selfish man - in the same letter he also asked that the house of canons in Worspring in Somerset be given to his father!
The final surrender came in 1545, the prior now one Thomas Luffenham who received a pension of 10 marks for his acquiesence. After the dissolution, the priory and lands passed to John, Lord Russell who quickly sold them on to Sir Robert Kirkham who turned the buildings into a home. The Kirkham's had owned extensive lands in and around Warmington in Cambridgeshire but had sold them to move to Fineshade. It's this connection which explains how the stone for the chapel at Fineshade came from Fotheringhay Castle which was demolished around 1625.
It remained with the Kirkhams until 1748 when it was sold to the trustees of William Payne King. He made extensive alterations to the house in 1750 including a particularly fine dining room with fine stucco and carved wood decorations. On his death it passed to his widow, Anne Maria, who remarried to the Hon. Edwin Sandys on 26 January 1769. Having no need for the estate, he sold it in the same year to the Hon. John Monckton (b.1739 - d.1830), son of the 1st Viscount Galway, and half-brother of the famous General Monckton. One interesting theory is that perhaps the particularly fine dining room was designed by James Paine during Monckton's ownership as he worked for Monckton's brother at Serlby Hall1. The house and estate stayed in the Monckton family until 1928 when it was sold to Charles R. d'Anyers Willis.
The history between 1928 and 1955 was something of a mystery - but thanks to an email some more details have emerged. It was demolished in 1956 following a demolition sale in November 1955 - possibly whilst in the 'care' of the local authority but this is unconfirmed. However, as always with these houses, fragments remain. A carved doorcase with pediment can be seen in the library of the Royal Society for the Encouragement of Arts, Manufactures & Commerce in London. Of the site itself, an open lawn marks the space where the house once stood, with the stables and other ancillary buildings now reused for other purposes leaving yet another estate without a focal point.
1 - 'An Inspector Recalls' - Derek Sherborn (2003) - pg.184